The better offer depends on what the viewer still needs after the tutorial delivers its promised result. Consider a video teaching marketers to build a campaign-tracking sheet. Some viewers need the tool used in the walkthrough because it will become part of their ongoing workflow. Others already have a spreadsheet tool; they want a ready-to-use version of the finished sheet.
An affiliate recommendation fits the first viewer. It is useful when the demonstrated tool makes the workflow easier in a way the video actually shows, rather than appearing as an unrelated offer at the end. The ongoing work is keeping the recommendation accurate as features, pricing, or the workflow change. Trust takes the hit if someone follows the tutorial and discovers that the recommended tool no longer does what the video promised.
A paid downloadable template fits the second viewer. The tutorial can teach the full method, while the purchase saves the time of rebuilding tabs, formulas, and labels. That is a different payoff from buying a tool. But the creator now owns the file’s upkeep and the questions that come with different reporting setups. A low-priced template can become an expensive support queue.
Neither choice wins just because its possible payout is higher. The useful decision is whether viewers are trying to adopt the demonstrated tool or skip the setup work after understanding it. What signals do you use to tell which of those intentions is stronger for a particular tutorial?